VELMOOR COLLEGE OF HEALTH SCIENCES Case Study Source Document — CHP Program Title: Reading the Room Student Scenario: Jerome Oduya, CHP 115 — Community Health Assessment --- BACKGROUND Jerome Oduya is a first-year Community Health Practice student completing a health communication assignment in CHP 115. His task is to evaluate two versions of a health awareness message aimed at a community audience and determine which message is more effective based on a structured rubric. The messages were written to address Type 2 diabetes prevention in a simulated urban neighborhood (the Lincoln Park district of a mid-sized Midwestern city — simulated). Both messages carry the same factual content but differ significantly in clarity, relevance, and actionability. Jerome and his classmates each scored both messages using the same five-criteria rubric. His assignment: compile the rubric results, write a brief analysis, and recommend one message for use in a community outreach flyer. --- MESSAGE A — Original Version "Type 2 diabetes mellitus is a chronic metabolic condition characterized by hyperglycemia resulting from insufficient insulin secretion or impaired insulin sensitivity. Epidemiological data indicates a statistically significant correlation between sedentary behavior, caloric surplus, and elevated HbA1c levels. Preventive interventions may include glycemic index management, structured aerobic programs, and regular HbA1c monitoring via primary care providers. Residents with risk factors are encouraged to consult their healthcare provider." --- MESSAGE B — Revised Version "Could you be at risk for Type 2 diabetes? Many people in our neighborhood are. The good news: small changes can make a real difference. Three steps to start today: 1. Take a 20-minute walk, three times a week. 2. Swap one sugary drink a day for water or unsweetened tea. 3. Talk to your doctor or health center about a free blood sugar test. Free diabetes risk screenings are available every Thursday, 10am–2pm, at the Lincoln Park Community Health Center (simulated). No appointment needed. Questions? Call 614-555-0180 or visit [simulated website]." --- RUBRIC SCORING RESULTS (5 REVIEWERS) Criteria rated 1–5 (1 = Poor, 5 = Excellent): Criteria 1 — Clarity of language (accessible to a general adult audience) Criteria 2 — Relevance to the target community (local context, familiar terms) Criteria 3 — Actionability (does it tell the audience what to do next?) Reviewer 1: MSG-A: Clarity=2, Relevance=2, Action=1 | MSG-B: Clarity=5, Relevance=5, Action=5 Reviewer 2: MSG-A: Clarity=1, Relevance=2, Action=1 | MSG-B: Clarity=4, Relevance=4, Action=5 Reviewer 3: MSG-A: Clarity=2, Relevance=1, Action=1 | MSG-B: Clarity=5, Relevance=5, Action=5 Reviewer 4: MSG-A: Clarity=1, Relevance=2, Action=2 | MSG-B: Clarity=5, Relevance=4, Action=5 Reviewer 5: MSG-A: Clarity=2, Relevance=2, Action=1 | MSG-B: Clarity=5, Relevance=5, Action=4 Averages: Message A: Clarity = 1.6, Relevance = 1.8, Action = 1.2 — TOTAL AVG = 1.53/5 Message B: Clarity = 4.8, Relevance = 4.6, Action = 4.8 — TOTAL AVG = 4.73/5 --- ANALYSIS Message A uses clinical language appropriate for a medical journal but inappropriate for a community health flyer intended for a general adult population. It contains no specific call to action and no local resource reference. It assumes the reader knows what "HbA1c" means and has an established relationship with a primary care provider. Message B uses plain language (grade 6–7 reading level), provides three concrete and achievable actions, references a specific local resource (simulated), includes a time and location for a free screening, and closes with a contact number. It follows the core principles of health literacy-informed communication. Recommendation: Message B should be used for the community flyer. Message A could be appropriate in a clinical or professional communication context (e.g., a staff training document or public health report). --- LEARNING OBJECTIVES (CHP 115 Alignment) 1. Apply a structured rubric to evaluate health communication materials. 2. Understand the concept of health literacy and its role in community outreach design. 3. Distinguish between clinical-language and plain-language communication styles. 4. Recognize the importance of actionability and local resource specificity in health messages. 5. Practice data-informed recommendation writing as a community health practitioner skill. --- DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. What is "health literacy," and why does it matter when designing community health materials? 2. What is the approximate reading level of Message A vs. Message B? (Hint: use a readability formula approach.) 3. Can you think of a situation where Message A's style would be appropriate and Message B's would not? 4. The free Thursday screening referenced in Message B is a simulated resource. If you were designing a real outreach campaign, how would you find and verify similar local resources? 5. What additional criteria would you add to the rubric to make it more comprehensive? --- INSTRUCTOR NOTES (DO NOT REPRODUCE ON STUDENT-FACING PAGE) This case maps to CHP 115 Week 7: Health Communication and Health Literacy. The simulated Lincoln Park district and Lincoln Park Community Health Center do not exist. The scoring rubric results are intentionally unambiguous — Message B clearly outperforms Message A — to allow beginning students to practice data interpretation without ambiguity. Advanced instructors may assign students to write a Message C that is a middle-ground attempt. Expected discussion time: 20–25 minutes. --- SOURCE DOCUMENT NOTES This document is a curricular clinical simulation exercise created for the Velmoor College of Health Sciences website. All people, places, and organizations referenced are simulated. Created for clinical instructional simulation purposes.