VELMOOR COLLEGE OF HEALTH SCIENCES Case Study Source Document — NAS Program Title: The Third Vital Sign Student Scenario: Amara Diallo, NAS 155 — Clinical Skills Lab II --- BACKGROUND Amara Diallo is a second-semester Nursing Assistant student completing her required clinical documentation exercises in NAS 155. The assignment requires her to review a set of 10 patient vital-sign records collected during a simulation lab session and identify any documentation errors before entering the data into a training log. The records were generated during a skills rotation in the Velmoor simulation lab. Each record represents one patient-simulator encounter during a 90-minute group session. Students took turns measuring temperature, pulse rate, respiratory rate, and oxygen saturation, then documented their findings on a standard form. Amara's task: Review all 10 records, verify that each field is correctly labeled, and flag any entry that does not match the expected measurement type. --- THE VITAL-SIGN RECORDS The table below shows the 10 records as they were written on the original lab form. Fields are: Patient ID, Temperature (°F), Pulse (bpm), Respiration (breaths/min), SpO2 (%), and Notes. Record 01: PT-01 | 98.4 | 76 | 16 | 98 | No concerns noted Record 02: PT-02 | 99.1 | 82 | 18 | 97 | Slight elevation in temp Record 03: PT-03 | 98.6 | 68 | 15 | 99 | Within normal limits Record 04: PT-04 | 97.9 | 91 | 20 | 96 | Elevated pulse; noted Record 05: PT-05 | 98.8 | 74 | 17 | 98 | No concerns noted Record 06: PT-06 | 99.3 | 85 | 19 | 97 | Temp above normal range Record 07: PT-07 | 98.5 | 14 | 72 | 99 | [NO NOTES — FIELD TRANSPOSITION ERROR] Record 08: PT-08 | 98.2 | 79 | 16 | 98 | No concerns noted Record 09: PT-09 | 98.7 | 88 | 18 | 96 | No concerns noted Record 10: PT-10 | 99.0 | 80 | 17 | 97 | No concerns noted --- THE ERROR — RECORD 07 In Record 07, the values for Pulse (bpm) and Respiration (breaths/min) have been transposed. The student who recorded PT-07 wrote "14" in the Pulse column and "72" in the Respiration column. These values are reversed: a pulse of 14 bpm would indicate severe bradycardia incompatible with normal consciousness, and a respiration rate of 72 breaths/min would indicate extreme tachypnea. The correct values (confirmed by the supervising instructor's reference record) are: Pulse = 72 bpm, Respiration = 14 breaths/min. This type of field transposition error — entering a value in the correct row but the wrong column — is one of the most common documentation errors in entry-level clinical work and can have serious consequences in live patient settings. --- LEARNING OBJECTIVES (NAS 155 Alignment) 1. Identify normal ranges for adult vital signs (temperature, pulse, respiration, SpO2). 2. Recognize documentation errors through cross-field plausibility checks. 3. Understand the clinical significance of a pulse reading of 14 bpm vs. 72 bpm. 4. Apply a systematic review process before submitting clinical documentation. 5. Communicate a documentation error clearly and professionally to a supervisor. --- DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. What is the normal adult range for resting pulse rate? For resting respiration rate? 2. Without looking at other records, what two signs in Record 07 should immediately raise a flag? 3. What would a pulse of 14 bpm indicate clinically? Could this patient be conscious and mobile? 4. How should a student correct a transposition error on a written form after the session ends? 5. If this were a real patient record in a clinical setting, who would you notify first, and how? --- INSTRUCTOR NOTES (DO NOT REPRODUCE ON STUDENT-FACING PAGE) The error in Record 07 was introduced intentionally. The correct values are Pulse = 72, Resp = 14. The simulation instructor confirmed these values. Students who catch only the pulse error (14) without also recognizing the implausibility of Resp = 72 should be prompted to explain what a respiratory rate of 72 would look like clinically. Expected discussion time: 20–25 minutes. This case maps to NAS 155 Week 6 lab review. --- SOURCE DOCUMENT NOTES This document is a curricular clinical simulation exercise created for the Velmoor College of Health Sciences website. It is not a record of actual clinical events. Patient IDs are simulated. All data was created for clinical instructional simulation purposes.